Heat
How does an EPDM rubber roof do in Florida heat?
EPDM has a long track record, but black rubber soaks up heat, and Florida is a cooling climate.
ERA explains the color choice. Black EPDM gets its sun resistance from carbon black, which turns UV rays into heat. White EPDM uses titanium dioxide, which reflects UV rays and protects the rubber. So black soaks up heat, and white bounces it back.
A trade magazine, Rubber News, once reported on the black versus white debate. A Firestone research and development director in that story said the usual break line for choosing white over black is the Mason-Dixon Line. He pointed to Chicago, which had 5,166 heating degree days to 1,262 cooling degree days in 2012. A heating degree day measures how much a place needs heat, and a cooling degree day measures how much it needs air conditioning. Florida sits on the other side of that line, where cooling matters most.
The same story had a Carlisle director of product marketing saying insulation drives energy use more than membrane color does. Insulation works day and night, while color only matters when the sun is out. Florida Solar Energy Center (FSEC) researchers studied reflective coatings on nine occupied Florida homes in the early 1990s. Average air conditioning savings were 19 percent, ranging from 2 to 43 percent, and savings depended on attic insulation and duct location. Those were coatings, not EPDM sheets, and reflectance dropped over time as algae and dirt built up.
What this means
Black EPDM is not a bad roof. It is a roof built for a different climate than Florida's. For a Florida home, ask about white EPDM or TPO, and ask your roofer to explain the attic insulation too.