Quality and warranty
How do you know the install was done right?
The roof should match the maker's instructions, the photos should show each step and the warranty paper should match what was installed.
Sheffield Metals says some warranties, including weathertightness warranties, rely on the installer following the maker's approved details. It also warns that a side lap warranty may cover seams only and not flashing zones, which it says is where most leaks occur. Ask which warranty you are getting and what it covers. Our roof warranty types guide explains the common kinds.
On Coastline jobs, Josh reviews every job through photo reports. Ask any roofer for photos of the deck, the underlayment and the trim before the panels hide them. Our what to expect during a roof replacement guide covers the full job from the homeowner's side.
Ask for photos at these points, because the panels will hide them:
- The bare deck after tear-off and repair.
- The underlayment, fully installed and lapped.
- The eave, rake and valley trim before panels cover the edges.
- Each pipe, vent and other opening once it is flashed.
How does metal hold up in a storm? After Hurricane Ian, a FEMA study reported by WUSF found that about 90 percent of homes with roofs installed before 2015 were damaged, versus 28 percent of homes with roofs installed after 2015, and that metal panel roofs were far less likely to be damaged and did not follow the same age pattern. That is about roofs in Ian's path, not a promise for any one roof. Quality of the install still decides the result. For price drivers, see metal roof cost in Florida.
Sheffield's own guide ends the install the same way McElroy's does: finish the details, then walk the whole roof and inspect it before the crew leaves. Ask your roofer to show you that final inspection in photos.