Why so many Ian roofs are still not right
The storm passed in 2022. The aftermath did not.
Ian was one of the most destructive hurricanes in Florida history, and it hit the Gulf Coast all at once. When a region loses tens of thousands of roofs in a single afternoon, the cleanup does not happen in an orderly line. Every reputable roofer was booked solid for months, materials were back-ordered, and adjusters were stretched across far more claims than they could handle. A lot of homeowners did the right thing, filed promptly and got in line, and still ended up waiting through the whole next year.
Into that gap rushed the storm chasers. Out-of-state crews flooded in, knocked on doors, collected deposits or signed Assignment of Benefits forms, threw a tarp on the roof, and in too many cases were never seen again. Some did partial work and walked. Some pulled a permit and never closed it. Others did the job so poorly that the "repair" is now its own problem. If your Ian project was started by a contractor who has since vanished or stopped answering the phone, you are far from alone, and that unfinished work is still your roof to deal with.
Some Ian damage did not show up until much later.
Not all storm damage announces itself. Ian lifted and creased shingles that did not blow off, loosened flashing, hairline-cracked tile, and worked fasteners loose without leaving an obvious hole. A roof like that can look fine from the street and shed water for a season or two, then start leaking once the next round of storms finishes what Ian started. By the time a brown stain shows up on a ceiling in 2024 or 2025, the underlying cause traces straight back to the 2022 storm, even though the symptom is brand new.
There is also the supplemental problem. Plenty of Ian claims were settled fast and cheap, before anyone got on the roof to see the full picture. Once a crew actually opens the roof up, they often find rotted decking, soaked insulation, or damage that the original scope never accounted for. The repair that was supposed to close the book on Ian turns out to be the moment you discover how much was missed the first time around.